Isn’t it always the way. You’ve been recommending something for 25 years with complete confidence. Then along comes a piece of very inconvenient evidence.
This time it’s about cats preferring moving water. It turns out that despite a whole industry devoted to promoting cat fountains, until now no one has bothered to see if they actually work.
It turns out that they don’t. At least not these ones. Hats off to these researchers for questioning what must have seemed like a no-brainer.
The Cat Fountain Study
Fourteen healthy cats were offered water from one of three types of bowl for two weeks each. Before each trial they were given a week to adjust before measurements began. The bowls were:
- A still water bowl (stainless steel)
- A circulating plastic water bowl (brand unknown)
- A free falling water bowl (Drinkwell® platinum)
Water intake, urine output and urine concentration were all measured for each two week period.
For all three types of bowls:
- Water intake was the same
- Urine output was the same
- Urine concentration was the same
So clearly, on average, healthy cats do not show a preference towards one specific style of water bowl. But there’s one interesting thing…
Three individual cats showed a marked preference for one particular bowl type. And you guessed it- each one preferred a different type!
Some limitations of this study might be:
- They didn’t try ceramic bowls
- The cats were healthy, not sick
- The cats lived in a lab, not a house
So what do we make of all this?
Should Cats Have Water Fountains?
The evidence does not support the widespread promotion of moving water for cats. However, there are clearly some cats who have strong individual preferences. We should therefore provide cats with a choice if water intake is a concern.
If you do this, it’s important to measure the results. This study showed that one cat actually drank still water better.
In the meantime, there are lots of other ways to get cats to drink more water that you can find here.
Robbins, M. T., Cline, M. G., Bartges, J. W., Felty, E., Saker, K. E., Bastian, R., & Witzel, A. L. (2018). Quantified water intake in laboratory cats from still, free-falling and circulating water bowls, and its effects on selected urinary parameters. Journal of feline medicine and surgery
By Andrew Spanner BVSc(Hons) MVetStud, a vet in Adelaide, Australia. These blogs are from a series regularly posted on Facebook and Twitter. Subscribe via email here to never miss a story!
Have something to add? Comments are welcome below and will appear within 24 hours of lodging.